It still remains unclear as to how the couple first originally met, but early reports of their relationship began to surface after TMZ released pictures of the pair staying at the Four Seasons in Maui in September 2021.

The tabloid originally labeled Jordan as a "mystery man" until Colton shared greater detail that November. Colton introduced Jordan to his family, and they announced their engagement in February 2022.

Colton and Jordan got married at Carneros Resort and Spa in Napa Valley, Calif., on May 13, 2023.

The reportedly three-day-long wedding hosted 200 guests, Stanford University's Artistic Swimmers, and a disco-themed pool party, per People.