Fans are divided on whether or not Juliette should be made to leave the show. “So is Juliette gone for good? Because I need to know if I should go with her,” one fan tweeted. Another seconded that sentiment, writing, “Is Juliette not coming back this season? Tell me now so I can take Siesta Key off my DVR.”

But not everyone thinks that Juliette’s behavior is acceptable. Juliette previously got into a fight with former cast member Chloe Trautman, punching her in the head and pulling her hair. A year prior, she reportedly kicked and punched Cara Geswelli at a bar. “Alex [Kompo] does something wrong and he is kicked off the show BUT Juliette is constantly abusing people and she is still on?? I hope her a-- is gone because she seems to always get away with it. Girl...go away,” one viewer said.

“Juliette deserves to be kicked off the show. I’m disgusted with her at this point. I hope she gets her a-- knocked out one day f--kin with the wrong one!!” another said.

While it doesn’t look like MTV is ready to part ways with Juliette just yet, we’ll have to wait and see if she does really follow Serena’s advice and stop these kinds of violent acts. Catch Siesta Key every Wednesday at 8 p.m. EST on MTV.