Jenny was a known figure before her Singled Out days. She started out as a Playboy model, even being named Playmate of the Year in 1994. She was able to leverage her fame from her modeling days to start a television career. She ultimately left Singled Out because she received an opportunity to have a much bigger role on screen.

In 1997, she not only got her own sitcom titled Jenny, but she also got her own sketch comedy show, The Jenny McCarthy Show, not to be confused with the other The Jenny McCarthy Show which was a talk show in 2013. Or the other, other The Jenny McCarthy Show, which the model continues to host on SiriusXM. Today, Jenny can be seen on The Masked Singer every Wednesday at 8 p.m. EST on Fox.

When the Playboy Playmate left Singled Out, she was replaced by model Carmen Electra for the final season of the show.