Bray Wyatt was married from 2012 to 2017 to Samantha Rotunda. The marriage ended after Samantha filed for divorce, claiming that Bray had cheated on her during the marriage. Samantha works as a real estate agent for Southern Belle Realty, and she has remarried since her divorce.

Following his marriage to Samantha, Bray was in a long-term relationship with WWE announcer Jojo Offerman, with some speculating that Bray had cheated on Samanta with Jojo. The two were in a relationship right up until the time of his death and got engaged in 2022.