The pair, who split after college, reconnected following Reagan’s divorce. "We had instant chemistry; it was like no time had passed at all," the mom-to-be recalled. "The last decade just went out the window and we picked up just right where we left off, when we were in our early 20s, like college kids."

Reagan explained that Reece reentered her life right when she was looking to start dating again. "It felt like serendipity. Like everything happened for a reason," the Louisiana native shared. "There’s no other way to describe it: it just feels right."