Tobey and his ex-wife, jewelry designer Jennifer Meyer, were married in 2007 and split up in 2016. The couple met in 2003 while Tobey was filming Seabiscuit. They announced their separation in 2016, but Jennifer officially filed for divorce in 2020. Together, Jennifer and Tobey co-parent two children: Ruby, 14, and Otis, 11.

Jennifer said that she and Tobey have been very successful at co-parenting and dished to Us in 2018 about why that is. "Remember that you love your kids equally more than anything in the world and that you want the best for them. If they see parents that don’t get along or fight, then they’re going to be unhappy, and nobody wants unhappy children," she said.

Following their divorce, Tobey began dating Tatiana, and Jennifer moved on with NBA agent Rich Paul, although it appears they have since broken up after he was spotted with Adele. Jennifer still gushes about her amicable relationship with Tobey and told Us in 2018, "He’s my best friend. He’s the greatest ex-husband a girl could ever have."

Maybe fans will see more of Tobey and Tatiana out and about now that he's reportedly featured in the latest Marvel blockbuster, Spider-Man: No Way Home. Tobey is also set to co-star in Damien Chazelle's 2022 flick Babylon about the Golden Age of Hollywood, although his role is currently under wraps.