Detective Lindsay was written out of Chicago P.D. in the Season 4 finale when she moved to New York City to work with the FBI. In real life, Sophia felt as though she was working her body too hard and running herself into the ground. She also told Dax Shepard during a December 2018 episode of his podcast Armchair Expert that she experienced "abusive behavior" on set.

Sophia is also among the women who backed the 2017 claims about One Tree Hill creator Mark Schwahn's sexual misconduct. Finding a solid home on a TV show has been an uphill battle for Sophia, and with Chicago P.D. is in her past, hopefully, her experience on Good Sam will be different.