Natalie is an ambitious, hard-working consulting manager who has a lot going for her! When she tried to sit Shayne down to discuss the future of their finances, he wasn’t on board with the idea of investing in 401(k)s. Despite the fact that she seemed visibly shocked by his response, and that he played mind games with her in the pods while he was still chatting up Shaine, Natalie has continued to push forward with Shayne as her dream guy.

Shayne also revealed to Natalie that he'd like to wear a tux cape on their big day, where he wants to have pizza, hot dogs, and mac and cheese on the menu. Shayne's requests didn’t mesh with Natalie’s wedding vibe at all. Nevertheless, she seems totally hell-bent on convincing others her relationship with Shayne is perfect — and fans are confused by that!