Lady Gaga's second engagement was to Christian Carino in 2018. She's always kept the details of her love life pretty private, so the crowd was shocked when she announced the engagement in her speech, saying she'd like to thank "her fiance, Christian."

The news was revealed at Elle's 25th annual Women in Hollywood in October 2018. Rumors of their engagement had been flying since the previous August when she was first spotted with a ring on *that* finger.

But their love story didn't last much longer, as their split was confirmed when Lady Gaga attended the Grammy's in 2019 without the talent agent — and without her engagement ring. A source told PEOPLE they had called off their engagement "a bit ago," saying “It just didn’t work out. Relationships sometimes end."

Before being engaged to Christian, Lady Gaga was engaged to actor Taylor Kinney. They broke off the engagement in 2016.