Before Genevieve changed her last name when she and Jared became husband and wife, she was previously Genevieve Cortese. They met when she played Ruby on the fourth season of Supernatural in 2008 and it was endgame from there. During a 2012 panel for the show, Jared commented on what it was like when they were first getting to know each other. "What made it work is that we got to know each other for about four months before we went on a date," he said. How sweet is that, though?

After just a year or so of dating, they got engaged in October of 2009 at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City in front of their favorite painting, Joan of Arc, painted in 1879 by French realist Jules Bastien-Lepage, Genevieve's mother told to Sun Valley Magazine.

A few months after the proposal, in 2010, Jared and Genevieve tied the knot in her hometown of Sun Valley, Idaho. They had a gorgeous outdoor winter wedding which really meant a lot to the both of them. "It was really important to me to share my love of the mountains with Jared’s family. Plus, we both love the outdoors as well as winter sports, and figured it was the perfect time to gather everyone together,” she told Inside Weddings.