On June 11, 2005, Jarecki married actress Alicia Silverstone in Lake Tahoe, California. Jarecki and Silverstone had four dogs.
Jarecki and Silverstone announced in January 2011 that they were expecting their first child. Silverstone gave birth to a son in May 2011.
Jarecki and Silverstone were divorced in February 2018 after 13 years of marriage. The couple filed for divorce in May 2018. The divorce was finalized in November 2018.
