Yes, Ashleigh can actually sing — and she has already done so in a few different roles we've already seen. On Riverdale and Katy Keene, she plays a woman named Josie McCoy. On Katy Keene, fans see Josie trying to make it big as a famous singer in NYC. But even though Ashleigh is able to do so, she's said it's "scary" because she's hard on herself and knows other people won't always have the nicest things to say.

"I always get nervous when I have to record, because I'm worried about what people are going to think, and I'm really critical of it, the same way I am of my acting," Ashleigh said in an interview with Elite Daily in 2020. "It's still very scary for me. There will be 10, 20, 50 more positive tweets about my voice, but I'll see that one [negative one] and it will affirm my own insecurity."

Later on, Ashleigh said that singing was never something she pursued professionally because she feels it's something she "won't succeed at," but she's willing to do it since it's a part of her job. She's confident in her abilities as an actress but doesn't have the same feelings about singing. But she also teases that her thoughts on all of that could change tomorrow and we might be on the lookout for her EP.