For a few years after her split from Erik Kuselia, Holly Sonders avoided dating in the public eye. Eventually, in 2019, rumors surfaced in the media regarding her potential romance with Kliff Kingsbury, the head coach of the Cardinals. On January 9, the model herself verified the rumors on Twitter.
They supposedly became together when Holly was working as a sideline reporter for the Big 12 Games and Kingsbury had recently divorced. Sonders and Kingsbury were sadly unable to stay together for very long.